Friday, November 27, 2009

CONCLUSION

Contributions


This study has provided insight into understanding the complexity of verbal bullying among adolescents. Bullying is becoming increasingly common among teenagers (Crick et al., 2001; ‘Enough is Enough’, 2006; Galen & Underwood, 1997; Marr & Field, 2001; Shariff, 2008), and now there is the growing issue of cyber-bullying (Beran & Li, 2005). Developing a better understanding of how and why verbal bullying happens is necessary, when issues like depression, anxiety, decreased self-esteem, eating disorders, and suicide (Kim, 2008) result. This study addressed components of verbal bullying among adolescents including medium choices, language use, emotions and behaviors associated, and personality traits.

The case study analysis provided a valuable in-depth look at four individual perspectives of verbal bullying among adolescents. The benefit of the case study allowed unique perspective differences to be highlighted, showing how personality traits in each case became the underlying factor that influenced how media was chosen, language was employed, and emotions and behaviors were associated, within bullying occurrences.

This study extends past research by incorporating verbal bullying medium choices with language use, and emotions and behaviors. Past research has emphasized ftf bullying among peers in school (Genta et al., 1996; Kumpulainen et al., 1998; Whitney & Smith, 1993). Even the National School Safety programs (N.S.S.S.C., 2009) encourages schools to focus primarily on traditional bullying inside the school grounds, ignoring the multi-media nature of bullying. Emotions and behaviors of bullies and victims have been studied according to popularity (Putallaz et al., 2007), biological sex (Crick & Bigbee, 1998; Crick & Grotpeter, 1996), and friendship satisfaction (Gini, 2007). Yet results of this study identify trait theory (McCrae & Costa, 1997) as an approach to look at personality, and how it accounts for differences between individual perceptions and behaviors.

This study has established developmental findings, which direct future bullying research. Examining these factors in adolescent bullying provides additional knowledge of how and why verbal bullying happens. Bullying is a social problem, particularly among adolescents. Further investigation of relational aggression is needed within adolescents who identify as bullies and bullied victims. Also, differences in relational influences between mediums should also be studied. This study offers a foundation of diverse individual perspectives about verbal bullying, which offers a guide for further academic analysis. This study provides information for resources to be developed, which can aid in prevention, monitoring, and coping with verbal bulling among adolescents.

Limitations

The primary limitation of this study is due to the case-study methodology. Although it provides an in-depth look at individual perspectives of adolescent verbal bullying, it is difficult to generalize perspectives of these participants to other adolescents. Current understandings of how and why verbal bullying among adolescents happens could be enhanced with a larger pool of participants, at a variety of demographic locations.

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

I. Introduction (1 page)
A. Provide background information for the study
B. State the goal of the study
C. State the rationale of the study
D. Preview the paper

Transition
To better understand the outcomes of verbal bullying among teenagers, it is imperative to understand how bullying happens and what the differences are between face-to-face and cyber-bullying.

II. Review of Literature (5.5 pages)
Synthesize the literature and provide an organized theoretically founded argument that demonstrates the emergence of the research questions.

A. Relational Outcomes

1. Establish how bullying is a communicative act.
2. Demonstrate how relational outcomes of bullying have been studied before.
3. Illustrate contradicting findings throughout the literature.


B. Medium Choices

1. Demonstrate how bullying has been studied in terms of medium choice.
2. Distinguish bullying from harassment online.
3. Connect with other studies that have looked at medium choice and different outcomes.

Transition
This study is guided by the following research questions: (RQs listed)

1. What relational outcomes does bullying have?
2. How is cyber-bullying defined by teenagers?
3. How does verbal bullying differ between face-to-face and cyber mediums?
4. Why does verbal bullying differ between face-to-face and cyber mediums?


III. Method (2.5 pages)
The goal of this section is to describe the data collection process, sample, and research procedures

A. Explain why I used a case study analysis.

B. Describe the participants

C. Describe the procedures including the recruitment and interview process.

D. Explain the data analysis and coding process.

Transition
These case studies represent unique perspectives on verbal bullying, and offer a range of understanding about the how and why factors involved.

IV. Results (6-7 pages)
The goal of this section is to explain and provide examples of each case study, demonstrating their uniqueness in perspectives on bullying.

A. Case Study 1

1. description and definition of codes
2. examples from transcripts

B. Case Study 2

1. description and definition of codes
2. examples from transcripts

C. Case Study 3

1. description and definition of codes
2. examples from transcripts

D. Case Study 4

1. description and definition of codes
2. examples from transcripts

Transition

V. Discussion (3-4 pages)
The goal of the section is connect the individual perspectives of bullying to understand this pertinent communicative phenomenon. It will also serve as the "so what" portion to the results.

A. Use theory to explain the results

B. Describe the narrative aspect occurring and the reasoning behind the interview responses.

C. Provide practical advice for teachers, parents and teenagers to consider when dealing with or preventing verbal bullying.

D. Tie into the review of literature to integrate the theoretical foundation these results are based on.

E. Provide the "why" to the results

F. Include the limitations and contribution section for the paper.

1. point out the theoretical contributions
2. provide practical contributions
3. discuss future research

Transition

Conclusion (1 page)
This gives an ending to the paper and ties everything together.

A. What we started with
B. What we found
C. Where we can go next